Sunday, August 23, 2009

Organics vs. Hydroponics

Let’s begin with a subject that always comes up in my grow classes: the difference between organics and hydroponics. Here’s my take on it; feel free to add your two cents worth, or call me on mine. I look forward to hearing from you!

While there are several forms of hydro, the general idea is that the roots of the plant hang in a solution of nutrients which supply the plant with all its fertilizer needs. The nutrients are derived from minerals which are usually mined in the desert. Organic growing, as it pertains to modern cannabis production, usually starts with a potting soil containing nutrients derived from animal feces. The plant must go through more metabolic processes to obtain what it needs from the organic nutrients mixed with the soil than it needs to in order to absorb nutrients from a hydroponic solution.

Organic soil growing is kind of like when a human eats a piece of bread. The stomach slowly converts the starch to sugar, which slowly goes out into the body and provides nourishment. Hydroponic growing, on the other hand, is like an intravenous drip of sucrose right into the bloodstream.

As a general rule, organically-grown medicinal cannabis tastes and smells better than hydro and also smokes smoother. For this reason, top-quality organic medicine commands a premium over hydro-grown. Organic hydroponics can be done, but is a more difficult proposition than utilizing mineral nutrients. Botanicare has a chart which shows how to replace the traditional General Hydroponics three-part formula with organics, a little at a time. These formulae can be used to add some organics to the traditional hydro mineral mixes, resulting in an enhanced taste and smell, or can be used to make the shift to 100% organic hydro. I have never actually undergone the GH to Botanicare / mineral to organic hydro conversion, but it seems like a pretty straightforward transition.

1 comment:

  1. Organic hyrdo seems like it's running behind the curve a little. The idea sounds so great... where are all the trials? Even a luminary such as yourself admits to never having tried the GH/Botanicare conversion.

    Perhaps there are a lot of people conducting A/B tests using organic on one plant and hydro/organic on an identical plant... but the results of their trials aren't being aggregated anywhere. Therefore, nobody else is benefitting from the things they have learned.

    Maybe your site could serve as a depository for organic/hydro research.

    I think that you, fearless leader, should take a leadership role and set up a test yourself. I would love to hear from a person of your experience, rather than a newbie who happened to try hydro first.

    Gary C

    ReplyDelete

About Me

Berkeley, CA, United States
Hello and Welcome to dharma Patients Cooperative! My name is D. Gold and I am the moderator of this blog. Over the years, I've written a few books on the subject of scientific cannabis study, starting with Cannabis Alchemy in 1972.I have taught many others the techniques for cultivating their own medicine. For the last two years or so, I have taught the Sunday afternoon grow class at Harborside Health Center in Oakland. (Every Sunday 2:00 to 6:00 pm. Always free!). While we cover beginning and advanced horticultural techniques, many other subjects come up in our weekly discussions that relate to medicinal cannabis and the movement. We hope to reflect these types of discussions in this blog. So feel free to start discussion topics, ask horticultural questions, share tips and new developments with other members, suggest ways that our community could be better served, promote activism, etc. Give us your two-cents worth. All suggestions are appreciated. Thanks. Dave

Followers